Im in a league and one guy I have scouted has 49 pts in the one game I scouted him for but only 3 star potential 5 star salary so only A- rating would he be worth taking over a 5/5 guy with A+ grade?
If he's 18 and the 5/5 A+ is 19, I could see an argument being made. If they're the same age, and especially if they're both 18, the 5/5 is absolutely the way to go, even putting aside that he's an A+ rather than an A-.