At these levels I often try to discount extra handling/driving points when TSP counting, which takes 3 points off P1 vs P2. That makes the decision even harder as you have the best inside player and best outside on either sides of the scale.
So pick between 1 or 3 based on who is most versatile or who fits your favourite / most used offence?
On the visible skills I'm going 3, he's a better defender and shooter (both make up for 1 less PA)