BuzzerBeater Forums

Bugs, bugs, bugs > changes in GE how coaches change plyrs?

changes in GE how coaches change plyrs? (thread closed)

Set priority
Show messages by
This Post:
00
77485.1
Date: 2/27/2009 1:22:41 PM
Overall Posts Rated:
167167
Ok, I posted this on the help forum too and didnt get an answer. So i am trying my luck here.

For the last 4 seasons I have always managed to get my guards the max amount off minutes for training. The way how I achieved this was simple. I selected no back up or reserve for either off the guard positions and just 1 back up for the other 3 positons. For every match i select 8 players and every match i just have 1 PG and 1 SG. I realised that this would cost me during games, but since I prefer a long term strategy I dont mind. Off course I needed to use strictly follow depth chart or else the coach would make a mess off it.

This has worked for 4 seasons perfectly until this season. The first game I noticed something was different was last week saturday. I had done the same thing, as I always do, and put a 9th player a small forward as reserve. It was a walk over and therefore I though either I hade made a misstake and not used strictly follow depth chart, the player got injured during playing or the extra player made the difference, because this reserve small forward played the last quarter instead off my guard. Let me emphasise again this has never happened before and the guard wasnt injured either...

So during the scrimmage from thursday i did the same thing again but left the 9th player out. used strictly follow depth chart selected only 1 PG and 1 SG and to my big suprise, (this game was never more than 20 points difference at any one time)... all my backups got minutes on the guard position.

It cant be that something that a tactic worked 4 seasons in a row, no longer works. This must either be a change that was implemented and not announced, which I cant imagine, or this must have been a bug what happened the last 2 matches. I hope someone can look into this for me and tell me which one off either scenarios is the case. I would like to know so I can anticipate on what to do next. Strictly following depth chart, clearly no longer works the way it used to work....

Looking forward to an answer


This Post:
00
77485.2 in reply to 77485.1
Date: 2/27/2009 2:47:58 PM
Overall Posts Rated:
699699
On your thursday scrimmage, your starter SG --> 6 PF.
On your last week scrimmage, your coach filled the court with your back ups at the beginning of the 4Q. If you choose "follow strictly...", there is a bug. It looks like a "Depth chart until 4th" behavior. I suggest you check your orders in the "former matches" drop down menu in "set your line up" so to make sure you didn't make any mistake.

This Post:
00
77485.3 in reply to 77485.2
Date: 2/28/2009 4:59:48 AM
Overall Posts Rated:
167167
i did double check again and in both cases i didnt make a misstake. i used strictly follow depth chart and the coach substituted at will...

On my last weeks saturday scrimmage game i put these players as my starters... And yes I used strcitly follow depth chart

starting pg: tavares no backup no reserve
starting sg: guardia no backup no reserve
starting sf: dey backup: lantz reserve: torres
starting pf: Yilong backup: mullan no reserve
starting c: Ebertz backup: breakwell no reserve

In my thursdays scrimmage I used strictly follow depth chart too and the coaching decisions were even more disastrous...

starting pg: Ortiz no backup no reserve
starting sg: McAvinchec no backup no reserve
starting sf: torres backup: dey reserve: torres
starting pf: Yilong backup: mullan no reserve
starting c: Ebertz backup: breakwell no reserve

like you i believe this is a bug too or an unanounced change in coach behaviour. (which I dont believe is the case) whatever it is, do BB developers read and act on these bug reports? Do i send this issue to a gm or directly to a BB developer? Any feedback from a GM or BB developer would be very welcome...

This Post:
00
77485.4 in reply to 77485.3
Date: 2/28/2009 6:54:39 AM
Overall Posts Rated:
959959
if you come to blowout torres will always play on the guard spot, because he is on the bench, and what should your coach do when someone gets his 6 fouls the sr won't let him play anymore.

This Post:
00
77485.5 in reply to 77485.4
Date: 2/28/2009 7:07:18 AM
Overall Posts Rated:
167167
* hides under the tables as fast as he can*

the first game i thought that might have happened. with regards to the second match i feel really totally incredible stupid... can someone pls close this thread? my god. how bloody stupid can someone be!!!

thanks for clearing it up...

This Post:
00
77485.6 in reply to 77485.3
Date: 2/28/2009 7:18:10 AM
Overall Posts Rated:
587587
do BB developers read and act on these bug reports?

Yep. That is pretty much the purpose of this forum.

It's more efficient to make public bug reports, as that allows users to see what has already been reported and for example share information on suspected bugs that in fact aren't bugs.

This Post:
00
77485.7 in reply to 77485.5
Date: 2/28/2009 7:25:57 AM
Overall Posts Rated:
959959
the first match i called it the 36+12 trick, search and easy opponent in scrimmage or when you have an bot in the cup you could easily arrange twelfe minutes for the backup :)

But i should stop taliking, because else this become to much ot and 2 this thread doesn't die^^