i understand your point but enthusiasm is way overrated there a 3 efforts you can choose from and you are proposing there should be two? if i were to choose i would reduce gameshape to 5 categories, just to have more consistency and not worry too much with the minutes. Putting the best team out there enables you to use TIE and not worry about the outcome of the game its not a huge deal for me because i have the highest salary in my league, gameshape is something that i am more concerned about because respectable to proficient (sublevels and all) affects my team's perfomance. i would love to have all players with prof gameshape and average enthusiasm, rather than med-aver gameshape and high enthusiasm --- that's just my opinion