BuzzerBeater Forums

If it is acceptable to share this level of detail, is the medium for sharing this detail acceptable?

[That is, should a collection of different discords, BB threads, etc., generally all conducting in English, a fair and appropriate way to share this info?]

Completely agree. Managers who spend more time in the game will naturally know more about how it works through their own observations and experimentation. It doesn't make sense to reward them because they happen to scour through the forums to find this information. I think it should all be published in the game manual at the very least and some kind of attention should be drawn to that through the news page.

Regardless, thank you Apex for making this thread!!

Completely agree. I spoke about it several months back too but there didn't seem to be any response...

I checked these with a BB and the second one is only for FDC but the first one is correct and I'll add them both on.

Thanks for the help!

Thanks, mate! What is FDC, btw? Oh gosh, you Americans love acronyms...

You're totally fine, I understood the intent of the comment. Just wanted to make that clear as well on my end that it was not posted without approval.

I think it's something thats always been an issue. The game manual has been outdated basically since 2010 when RiP posted his Guide to BB which was updated again in 2016 (I believe those were the correct years). It's never really been just a game manual that we've had access to with BB's answering questions but the answers have gotten more specific.

Part of the reason if I had to guess was for them to work on and improve features they talk about their implementation a bit more in depth to seek suggestions on changes. The stamina, substitution, game engine, and tactical changes had to do with discussions pertaining how to fix short rosters and recent exhaustion mechanics.

I know some BB's want everything hidden and others want more information available to users. I can't get into many details on here but if certain people had their way we wouldn't get any updates in news posts at all. We'd just be surprised when the site works entirely differently which I think would upset a lot of users. It's a balancing act for sure.

Yeah used to be SFDC but Strictly was removed so now it's just FDC.

That's a good point though, let me go remove as many acronyms as I can so the post can be auto-translated a bit easier. Also if LA's do come around it would be easier for them as well.

Another useful piece of info here, mate. Thumbs up!

- All training gives you 10% of the training amount to a random skill. The gym gives you 1, 2, or 3 more of those based on level.

I strongly doubt that this is accurate though... Have you confirmed those numbers with the BBs?

As far as I remember, cross-training used to depend on the extremity of the discrepancy in the different skill levels. A well rounded player would, in general, get a smaller "penalty" than a more one-sided fellow. In other words the cross-training deduction varies from player to player but the cross-training "bonus" is fixed. Which would in turn lead to somewhat slower training for unbalanced players.

Lastly, I am almost certain that the cross-training boost is much smaller that 10% per level. In the manual/user knowledge base they talk about additional slots and I agree - there is one additional slot of each level of the gym. No one specifically said however (or at least I have not come across this) that all pre-gym cross-training goes to just one slot. My educated guess would be that there are two or three slots without gym (~2-4% each), so each level of the building would increase cross-training effects by merely 2-4%, not 10%.

I would much appreciate your thoughts on this particular subject.

I was surprised too, none of this is guessing however. All of this was posted by a BB on the forums and then looked over and approved for posting by a BB as well. So it's been confirmed by a BB not once, but twice.

However, I can go into my interpretation of the details a bit more unofficially (nothing I comment to you is actually official, the only thing I've confirmed being the main post). The 10% is 10% of the training amount, so if you have an older player, or got less minutes, or are training something that trains slowly, that 10% will be much smaller. It doesn't mean the skill gets 0.10 further in progression.

As an 18 year old, training something like 1v1, you'd get the max amount from these crosses. However as the player even gets to 21-22, 10% of that training is about 70% or so of what you'd see at 18 and thus so is every single cross-training as well. That's sort of where it all evens out in my eyes and the gym might play a much larger role in producing the high TSP we see at the U21 level now. We all believed it was mostly in the Youth Trainer, but I think both played a factor in the +15 or so TSP we see after the buffs.