BuzzerBeater Forums

Help - English > Is it worth training HA for a defensive big first

Is it worth training HA for a defensive big first

Set priority
Show messages by
This Post:
11
321576.17 in reply to 321576.15
Date: 10/14/2023 10:57:34 AM
Internazionale Torreense
II.2
Overall Posts Rated:
151151
Second Team:
Internazionale Sporting
Where did I get this info? Literally every single thread that I have read, also there is a thread about the elastic effect coefficient

If you really did your research you would have noticed that on coach parrot there are the coefficients for the elastic effect of skills, if you don't know about that then you should try a little bit more instead of stating fake info as truth in public threads for others to see, especially newbies that don't know anything about this game.

It's a bit tiring to read your uninformed replies and assumptions in many threads, it's also dangerous for other uninformed players or newbies as they may assume your misinformation as truth. Instead of assuming and stating things openly and plainly, when you don't know or are not sure about something write in a way that you ask questions, which would help improve the quality of information on the threads you are active on, just my 2 cents

This Post:
00
321576.18 in reply to 321576.17
Date: 10/14/2023 8:43:40 PM
Tampines Fusion
SBBL
Overall Posts Rated:
433433
It's a bit tiring to read your uninformed replies and assumptions in many threads, it's also dangerous for other uninformed players or newbies as they may assume your misinformation as truth. Instead of assuming and stating things openly and plainly, when you don't know or are not sure about something write in a way that you ask questions, which would help improve the quality of information on the threads you are active on, just my 2 cents.

I have ever said everything I said were set in stone. Which is why I always ask questions when people bring up things. I don't come up with my own info, I go through a lot of forum posts and base my ideas from there. If someone comes up with something more convincing or solid, then I will stick to that.

If you're so annoyed by my wrong info, why don't you come out more often to share? ;)

This Post:
00
321576.19 in reply to 321576.16
Date: 10/14/2023 8:49:40 PM
Tampines Fusion
SBBL
Overall Posts Rated:
433433
The original analysis by wozzvt showed that it was HA elastically linked to OD, not DR.

It's hard to disentangle because most things that train HA also train DR. But, his analysis showed that HA was more important and very likely the driving factor.

Ah, thanks for the info. Now I have to change what I look out for when training XD

This Post:
11
321576.20 in reply to 321576.18
Date: 10/15/2023 1:45:43 AM
Woodbridge Wreckers
DBA Pro A
Overall Posts Rated:
13931393
It might help to differentiate the things you've read (for example: a lot of people train 1v1 for the elastic effect) and your own ideas/conclusions (1v1 trains DR mainly, so DR causes the elastic effect for OD).

We can agree on the first observation, but your conclusion based on that observation might be wrong.

This Post:
11
321576.21 in reply to 321576.18
Date: 10/15/2023 10:03:06 AM
Internazionale Torreense
II.2
Overall Posts Rated:
151151
Second Team:
Internazionale Sporting
I am not annoyed, I am giving you directions on how to improve the way you question, simple as that

It's exactly as Jerundebar said

You don't question, you state affirmations

"Does HA give elastics to OD, or is it DR, or both?
This is actually the first training thread I've read which actually talked about HA. Every other thread seem to focus solely on DR. Is that because DR gives more elastics than HA?"

You started of well but then your line of reasoning derailed completely, not only you stated your own assumption as an affirmation, you also misinterpreted the information you saw on the forum and stated it as an affirmation.


1. "This is actually the first training thread I've read which actually talked about HA"

I am 1000% certain it's not, I have read a lot of threads on the forums, ESPECIALLY I researched almost all of the training guides in the USA forums, Polska, Dutch, Austrian, Spanish, Peru, Argentina, Taiwan, China, you name it. In every single country forum and even in the english global forum you will find the info that HA gives elastic effect to OD. You don't find that about DR.

2. "Every other thread seem to focus solely on DR. Is that because DR gives more elastics than HA?"

This is your misinterpretation, every other thread does not focus on Dr, very probably what you are assuming is that people suggest to get your DR, HA, to 16/17 then train OD.

And you are assuming this as DR gives elastics to OD. What in reality this means is that

1v1F training or 1v1G are the most popular training plans for the 18/19 age bracket, and the recommended onees, because of the quantity of pops, and also because of the elastic setup it gives to OD, and some other skills.

It is common knowledge that you should get your DR/HA to 16/17 before switching to OD, and that is because it does not make sense to only train HA to 16/17 and then give OD training.

Because 1v1F trains JS, DR, HA, IS, that's why most people say to give DR/HA to 16/17 because then when you switch to OD your trainee will have enough pops, enough JS, enough IS, and enough HA to give OD elastics so this is the OPTIMAL way to train a player.

I hope this reply was helpful to you and don't take me as annoyed because I am not, I am simply trying to improve your line of reasoning and communication, cheers!

Last edited by Coach Sergio at 10/15/2023 10:13:44 AM

This Post:
00
321576.22 in reply to 321576.20
Date: 10/15/2023 10:29:44 AM
Tampines Fusion
SBBL
Overall Posts Rated:
433433
your own ideas/conclusions (1v1 trains DR mainly, so DR causes the elastic effect for OD).

No this isn't even my own conclusion. I did read it up in the forums more than once. Since no one stepped in to correct them all this while, I just took it as it was supposed to.

This Post:
00
321576.23 in reply to 321576.21
Date: 10/15/2023 10:42:03 AM
Tampines Fusion
SBBL
Overall Posts Rated:
433433
I am 1000% certain it's not, I have read a lot of threads on the forums, ESPECIALLY I researched almost all of the training guides in the USA forums, Polska, Dutch, Austrian, Spanish, Peru, Argentina, Taiwan, China, you name it. In every single country forum and even in the english global forum you will find the info that HA gives elastic effect to OD. You don't find that about DR.

I don't read country forums, so maybe that's why I miss out on a lot of into. But you are very wrong about it not showing up in the help forums. It wasn't my own assumption that DR gives elastics to OD. I read it up a few times, no one corrected it. And yes, with so many threads I am pretty sure I've never read anything about HA befor - maybe I missed out on it, but I certainly have not come across any in recent memory. Again, none of those are my own assumptions, so please don't assume that they are.

That said, I really appreciated that you actually came out to help me while also providing reliable sources. As I said, no one corrected those who gave out wrong info in the past, so that's what I learned. Things would certainly be better if you all come out to help us out more often, rather than keeping it within your community. I know you all have the right to keep your own secrets within your community if you want, but again, if it bothers you that misinformation is spread around, come out more often. Your knowledge would be greatly appreciated (or at least I would love to learn more of it).

This Post:
22
321576.24 in reply to 321576.23
Date: 10/15/2023 11:20:21 AM
Internazionale Torreense
II.2
Overall Posts Rated:
151151
Second Team:
Internazionale Sporting
Would you be as kind as referencing the resources that you state, where DR is corelated to elastics for OD?

I don't want to be rude, but having read a lot on the forums myself I didn't really find threads where DR is corelated to OD.

Anyway, no worries, we are here to help! I have sent you a message with some great resources, feel free to check whenever you have time!

Last edited by Coach Sergio at 10/15/2023 11:25:56 AM

This Post:
00
321576.25 in reply to 321576.24
Date: 10/16/2023 6:17:08 AM
Tampines Fusion
SBBL
Overall Posts Rated:
433433
No harm with you asking, tho I honestly have no idea how I am supposed to dig them up for you. That said, I would know what to respond if I ever see one again xD

Appreciate your DM, haven't read it yet but glad for the help. Thanks a lot.

This Post:
33
321576.26 in reply to 321576.22
Date: 10/16/2023 11:56:46 AM
Woodbridge Wreckers
DBA Pro A
Overall Posts Rated:
13931393
I think you really need to think critically about the way you're thinking. Because somewhere you've drawn your own conclusion and stuck to it. I've looked up the last 10 or so topics about training and elasticity, and the only person recently claiming that DR creates elasticity for OD is you. Most posts say HA creates elasticity, and you're even commenting in those posts like (318368.6) and (316210.22)!

There are a couple of posts claiming both DR and HA create elastic effect for OD, and I found 1 post from last year that claims DR creates the elastic effect for OD (you also posted there). That's why you should be very critical with what you read, as anyone can post on the forums and make a claim. You are also part of this by copying such claims without veryfing the source, thereby and misinforming new managers that can also then misinform others.
It's not always on purpose, sometimes language can be a barrier. Like DR can also mean Defensive Rebounding, and if you're not aware that people mean Driving when they say DR things can get mixed up.

But there's no way that a majority of posts say that DR creates the elastic effect for OD, and I'm afraid you might suffer from confirmation bias that makes you (unconciously) ignore information that contradicts your current knowledge. Again I haven't gone far in the past to track where you first got the believe that DR was the elastic effect.

I get your request for people to step in and correct false information, but it's hard to stop because people keep posting false claims. I've tried to do it for some time, but I gave up. Everyone should do their part, and it starts with being critical with what you read and stopping to spread misinformation.

Last edited by Jeründerbar at 10/16/2023 12:01:51 PM

Advertisement