I think your right about the strangeness of the All-Star Game, but you need to remember that it is a game all about Offense, there is nearly no D played, so the team with the more dominant O is usually going to pip out the other. If you look at D3vils in the league games, there is not a lot of diff in the points diff, it may be the case that the guys selected had great O skills for this Div but over all the teams D is secondary.
I think it will be a great finish and interesting to see who goes for it and when...