That is a good idea, but that might open up a new can of worms(not that it is a bad thing). I mean, you can do that to the defensive side too. Can you imagine the decisions you would have to make concerning your best defense or the defense more equal to the type of offense your opponent is playing?
Here is something else to think about. What if each player had a rating on each of the offenses and defensive tactics? That way you could base your whole offense to make the teams offensive flow run smoother. A percentage scale would be good. For example, we got a player who is 50% run and gun, 25% motion, 25% base. In his next game he plays in the run and gun. After the game, he is now 55% run and gun and either motion or base loses 5%. Or do you you think a point system would be better?