I almost never run Crunch Time. It's an enthusiasm killer for sure.
I was very surprised by my win against Cold Fish, honestly. At the time though, Cold Fish had quite a few injured players. Now that they're all healthy, I'm not certain of victory. I might try Princeton against them to allow all my players a chance to score from inside and outside. Even then, my defense isn't so great. I don't really plan on beating him. I'm probably going to stick around D-4 for a few more seasons, expanding my arena and building up a better team.
Good luck against Maui.