I'd love to offer advice, but this is about my fourth restart at Div 2, only one of which has lasted beyond a season, so I doubt I'm the guy to help you get consistency in your team. What I have noticed, however, is you can't just run with an A team week in, week out, because it will get you wins early in the season, but by the end of the season the stronger guys will be in better shape than you and just roll over you. That's been my experience in each of my losing runs at Div 2.