Personally, I don't think experience makes any difference between two players with the same skills.
And this is coming from a NT coach? Are you sure you are qualified for the job??
Yeah, that's coming from a NT coach. And if you don't have actual data to prove the otherwise, please don't be so ordinary to jump into stupid conclusions. Instead, you should probably ask yourself if what you think you know is actually right, or you might probably think it wrong. In simple words, what you think is right, might be wrong. Again, I use the "if, might, probably" because I have the decency to respect others opinion.
What actually is proven to work in the 4th quarter, is Stamina. You might want to learn that to improve your team ;)