BuzzerBeater Forums

Suggestions > Remove Injuries

Remove Injuries (thread closed)

Set priority
Show messages by
This Post:
00
215737.27 in reply to 215737.25
Date: 5/8/2012 12:44:17 PM
Overall Posts Rated:
105105
LCD plays starters too much and isnt ideal for training. SFDC is my pref setting for min and training purposes, but it's rigid and if an injury occurs you're in trouble.
I totaly agree.
Currently, it does NOT function as intended.

One would expect (and as described) the following:
1) SFDC - In case there are subs, it will go upon the DC. The minutes will be upon DC as well.

2) LCD - The coach can do anything he thinks and decides. BUT, it is expected to be logic...
To give a player who is best as C to play his worse position (PG), and not due to the fact that the other alternatives are worse, is an algorithm bug as well.

3) FDC - The minutes and subs will be upon DC, but the coach has some say about that.
It means, that he can play by SOME DEGREE with that, and not to throw all tactic into the garbage when the game begins (which is exactly what currently happens and should NOT happen).

4) FDD from 4th Q - An expected combination between (3) and (2).

Currently there is only real one option to choose - (1).
All the others are just misleading, and causing lots of unexpected trouble to those who do uses them.
One can at least expect that they will be blocked...

This Post:
00
215737.28 in reply to 215737.27
Date: 5/8/2012 12:55:45 PM
Overall Posts Rated:
573573
As I said, I definitely agree that substitution patterns currently are very idiosyncratic, and could certainly be better described, and hopefully changed at some point. But that's a completely different topic than the Injuries discussion in this thread.

From: Kukoc
This Post:
11
215737.29 in reply to 215737.28
Date: 5/8/2012 1:59:44 PM
Overall Posts Rated:
13361336
Imo currently it's simple. Don't care about minutes and want to win whatever it takes → LCD. Want some predictability in minutes and get your weak trainees in for minutes SFDC.
Yes injuries do screw up minutes, but that's why you have a 12 player roster set up for games. Too many or too early fouls might also screw up minutes, let's eliminate fouls in game aswell?

From: brian

This Post:
00
215737.30 in reply to 215737.26
Date: 5/8/2012 2:08:55 PM
Overall Posts Rated:
576576
There are endless examples of this in real sports, and it makes for great drama and great debates!


I can see some silver-lining examples of drama created by injury, but would much prefer to see healthy fully available teams and superstars battle it out.

The eastern conference playoffs would be much more interesting if rose, noah, howard, josh smith, jeremy lin, amare (im sure im missing others) were 100% healthy. No doubt that will be reflected in TV ratings as well.

"Well, no ones gonna top that." - http://tinyurl.com/noigttt
From: Tangosz

This Post:
00
215737.31 in reply to 215737.30
Date: 5/8/2012 2:10:31 PM
Overall Posts Rated:
573573
Sadly, I don't think anything would make the NBA playoffs more exciting, or exciting at all. :)

From: brian

This Post:
00
215737.32 in reply to 215737.29
Date: 5/8/2012 2:12:09 PM
Overall Posts Rated:
576576
let's eliminate fouls in game aswell?


Nice strawman. Thats not what I suggested.

"Well, no ones gonna top that." - http://tinyurl.com/noigttt
This Post:
00
215737.33 in reply to 215737.29
Date: 5/8/2012 2:20:07 PM
Overall Posts Rated:
105105
Imo currently it's simple. Don't care about minutes and want to win whatever it takes → LCD. Want some predictability in minutes and get your weak trainees in for minutes SFDC.
Yes injuries do screw up minutes, but that's why you have a 12 player roster set up for games. Too many or too early fouls might also screw up minutes, let's eliminate fouls in game aswell?
Except that we continue to discuss off topic here, this is not an excuse for a feature not functioning.
It should be fixed, removed or at least having an explanation for what it actually does...

From: CrazyEye

This Post:
00
215737.34 in reply to 215737.32
Date: 5/8/2012 2:20:46 PM
Overall Posts Rated:
959959
but it goes into the same direction, if rose can't get injured to don't ruin minutes and let the superstars battle it out . Foul trouble leads to the same.

And having a deep bench helps a bit, to injurys at the same position are crap like in your case but it isnÄt like too injured player are close to common. maybe that one problem, but i would either raise then then eleminate then.

From: brian

This Post:
00
215737.35 in reply to 215737.34
Date: 5/8/2012 2:27:14 PM
Overall Posts Rated:
576576
Similar but different, particularly as some players are more prone to fouls and if you investigate that as a buyer then you assume the risk. Fouls effect every game. Injuries might only happen once every 10 games, or, suddenly twice in a game 3 of the finals.

Again, that's not what im suggesting and effects the game in a much different, more fundamental way.

"Well, no ones gonna top that." - http://tinyurl.com/noigttt
From: Kukoc

This Post:
00
215737.36 in reply to 215737.35
Date: 5/8/2012 2:48:19 PM
Overall Posts Rated:
13361336
But there are players that are more prone to injuries than others. Should you not try to get rid of those players in order to minimize the injuries? Perhaps adding injury history to players would be cool.
And thanks for giving me a superhero name!

Last edited by Kukoc at 5/8/2012 2:48:49 PM

This Post:
00
215737.37 in reply to 215737.35
Date: 5/8/2012 2:49:43 PM
Overall Posts Rated:
105105
I think the suggestion, as given, is wrong, but I agree that there is something in that.

I think on a different, and more realistic, proposal.
Currently during season, I guess they are taking mainly the last X (3-4 I guess) games, and the current game into one formula of randmoness.
Hopefully, they are also taking the level of effort (TIE, REG or CT) as well.

I think that for the playoff, a different method should be taken.
First, taking into consideration the total minutes played this season (will also affect the phenomenon of buying best players of a team just before playoff time).
Not taking into consideration the current game minutes (but taking the effort as well).
Using a different randomness formula, as during playoff, usually there are less injuries, as teams' coaches usually taking more care for getting to that crucial moment as fit as possible. [although there are accidence - Rose... Davis... etc.]

Last edited by Pini פיני at 5/8/2012 2:50:21 PM

Advertisement