Hey Maggot the linked thread contains this from me.
What would be a good idea is if new players could get to create one player. He should be 18, height specified, position specified, nationality same as team, name specified, all star potential (not crippling but not national team potential) and starting salary around $4,000. A good solid trainee that the player will identify with.
This is the sort of thing that may encourage new users to keep on playing, a really solid player that they identify with right from the start.
Maybe it could also be provided as a once off option for older teams during the offseason for some sort of massive fee. Guys like that on the TL typically go for $100,000 or less so if teams were able to purchase a "unique" rookie once in their teams history during the offseason for maybe $300,000 I don't think it would hurt the balance of the game at all.
I have thought about this since. I think the option would be simple. Every new team when they sign up and enter their team name and stadium name would also enter a player name and position. Then that "standard" player is created for them.
I will detail exactly what I think those players should be like later.
I also think every existing team that never had this opportunity should get a once off opportunity to also get a "original" player. For existing teams the option should be in the offseason at the same time as you can rename your team. He would then turn up as your 3rd round draft pick. I originally said $300,000. Some have also suggested $5 in real cash might be ok, but it does set an ugly precedent that you can buy extra perks which had always been against the spirit of the game. I think if you get a player who is worth roughly $50,000 on the TL but he is from your nation and is your draft pick so double to sextuple is the proper range I guess.
So *roughly* here are my players.
PG - 6'2" JS 6 JR 5 OD 6 HA 6 DR 5 PA 7 all else 4 salary about $3662.
SG - 6'5" JS 7 JR 6 OD 6 HA 5 DR 7 PA 5 all else 4 salary about $3770.
SF - 6'8" JS 7 OD 6 all else 5 salary about $3900.
PF - 6'10" JS 6 IS 5 ID 6 RE 7 all else 4 about $3739.
C - 7'0" IS 7 ID 6 RE 5 SB 6 all else 4 about $3698.
I don't think any of these players would break the game. Guys like them can be easily found on the TL for about $30,000-$80,000 except for the SF, maybe he is a bit good, but SFs are so hard to train I thought he needed help.
People thought All-Sart potential was too much (I don't) but if they are really worried you can fix these players at Star potential instead. Easy.
What do you think?