For basketball online just Buzzerbeater. I checked Charazay's game manual without signing up and 17 weeks was a turn off. I used to play a fair few football (the world game) managers, primarily Managerzone and Trophy Manager. Dabbled with Hattrick but their season setup and at the time insistence on collecting real names meant I didn't stay.
So to answer the question properly, a few NBA 2k's over the years (12, 18, 20). I only bought 12 (the one where it was difficult to beat anyone off the dribble). 18 came with my console (the less said about that the better), 20 was PS Plus (felt pretty good, though I was comparing it to my previous experience on 18).
The question of course baits another one; have you seen another comeback as wild as this on any basketball game? I can't remember one, and even the IRL Tracy McGrady outburst (13 points 33 seconds) was only a 10 point last minute comeback.