BuzzerBeater Forums

Suggestions > All-Star week suggestion

All-Star week suggestion

Set priority
Show messages by
This Post:
00
175327.4 in reply to 175327.3
Date: 2/22/2011 4:30:43 PM
Overall Posts Rated:
1717
I would love this, but if you were the manager you would be able to see all the players' attributes :(

Maybe those are hidden when you pick the team and you youd just have to guess/assume if the player has good OD or something haha

This Post:
00
175327.5 in reply to 175327.4
Date: 2/23/2011 12:28:00 AM
Arizona Cacti
II.3
Overall Posts Rated:
276276
Yea part of the original post mentioned that you would not get to see player's skills. Most managers who this would be fun for pay attention to players in their league however and would have a good ballpark idea of what skills their all-stars have.

I'd like to make an addition though, instead of having some kind of convoluted voting process simply let the best manager who wants to manage the game manage it. Under the 'All-Star Weekend' tab there could be a checkbox that you click which says I'd like to manage my conference's all-star team. Then the best team in the standings who has clicked this box gets to set lineups.

I think this would be fun!

This Post:
00
175327.6 in reply to 175327.5
Date: 2/23/2011 12:34:19 AM
Overall Posts Rated:
534534
convoluted voting process? I donn´t know exactly wat convoluted means but i can imagine. Convolution it´s great for forums. Most of the forums in lower divisions are simply dead. It will inccentivate managers to make a campain, use the forum and generate new rivlaries. I think it would be better than letting the better team to make the desition, but even like that, it would be better than it is now.

This Post:
00
175327.7 in reply to 175327.3
Date: 2/23/2011 2:43:31 AM
Overall Posts Rated:
406406
2º) The manager can select players of any team to play in any position. Giving an oportunity for those players training away from his natural position. Obiusly you can not see their skills, but you can take your decision based on statistics and salary.


2 problems arise here.

1. you want to give training minutes for the allstar game - I dont like it

2. if a manager can pick the allstars himself I guess this would more often than not mean that this players allstar-team (or at least a big amount of the allstars selection) would be his own players.

This Post:
00
175327.8 in reply to 175327.7
Date: 2/23/2011 3:52:55 AM
Overall Posts Rated:
959959
2º) The manager can select players of any team to play in any position. Giving an oportunity for those players training away from his natural position. Obiusly you can not see their skills, but you can take your decision based on statistics and salary.


2 problems arise here.

1. you want to give training minutes for the allstar game - I dont like it

2. if a manager can pick the allstars himself I guess this would more often than not mean that this players allstar-team (or at least a big amount of the allstars selection) would be his own players.


about2 i also don't see a more objective vote by the manager, and with the actual asd engine the vote and the player with the best stats is the intresting part of the ASD.
And that why i don't like tactics like Run and Gun or look inside there, ASD is a game for Fun to show who the best in the div and who pick the best tactic(and maybe i don't want my C to be a passing station for the guards there^^).

Also i won't give the skills to my opponents, if i like to do so i would put them constantly on sale and someone winning a stupid vote shouldn't change this.

This Post:
00
175327.9 in reply to 175327.6
Date: 2/23/2011 1:32:35 PM
Arizona Cacti
II.3
Overall Posts Rated:
276276
This will not cause many lower level managers to care. The ones who don't post on forums still won't post and then you're stuck voting for teams who don't show up. Also, I could see people voting for less deserving teams who don't deserve to the position because they dislike the #1 who always beats up on them in league play.

This Post:
00
175327.10 in reply to 175327.7
Date: 2/23/2011 5:39:11 PM
Overall Posts Rated:
534534
I don´t think the players should have minutes for training. Perhaps i did not express my self correctly. I am thinking in a system similar to the national team but without experience too.

This Post:
00
175327.11 in reply to 175327.10
Date: 2/23/2011 11:04:39 PM
Overall Posts Rated:
137137
Dunk contest!

This Post:
00
175327.12 in reply to 175327.11
Date: 2/24/2011 9:55:06 AM
Overall Posts Rated:
404404
My idea for ASG is to change the way players are selected

Actually there is a list of players voted by the fan.My idea is that managers can chooose,among those players in list,1 players per role.The players with more votes by managers will play the ASG;among two players with an equal number of human votes,will play the ASG the player with the higher fan vote

It could be a way to involve more the managers in the ASG without changing drammatically the system