Got it, think I read the question too quickly! I do think OD normally shuts down the other person's main skills. My team plays respectable high to strong medium OD in Div V and I always shut down teams that have higher offensive flow and outside shooting, though since I have focused on OD for a couple of years my guards aren't exactly lighting it up from outside. From reading up on OD before I started training it I came across others who believed that while OD is the most significant individual skill, guards with a high combination of passing and handling should be able to do well against guards with high OD. But since I've only been in the league for 3 years in Div V I can't really speak to that.
I wish there were pigmen. You get a few of these pigmen walking around I'm looking a whole lot better. Then if somebody wants to fix me up at least they could say, Hey he's no pig-man!