BuzzerBeater Forums

So instead make it complety random? I think it should be within the reach of the manager how gameshape develops, there´s already plenty randomness in the game by schedule, cup draw and injuries, no need to "dice it up" anymore.

i don't like your suggestion and think after the offseason you have a fresh start and then i like constant more then random and eliminating after the offseason amkes sense, cause of the different number of games etc.

But as i said suggestion, so it goes to the suggestion forum.

I think one of the advantages of it being made to 'respectable' at the start of the season for everyone, is that everyone starts on the same page.

If it were random, you would find people complaining that something 'random' caused them to lose a game.

There are already so many factors in this game which, take a very good manager to control, and i believe the last thing we need is something 'random' thrown in there to cause chaos.

In principle the idea is sound, in that yes all players do not come back from off season out of shape. But in real life this is becoming elss and less. In some sporting leagues here in Oz, there are clauses in peoples contract's that state they must not come back from off-season more than X Kg's overweight.
So i think that having all players come back from off-season as respectable, is still a ok with me. Its equal, everyone is in the same boat so there is no unfairness etc.

Horrible idea. So my $200,000 star will come back in atrocious GS randomly and I will lost my first 6 games. You are joking right?

All I read is that GS is random... I thought we had some control over GS by managing the minutes the players play in each week. I still do not see any real argument as to why getting rid of GS reset is an absurd idea so far.

Last edited by lopokomo at 12/1/2011 10:59:10 AM

GS is not random at all. There are many threads that give advice on how to manager and maintain GS. GS can be managed, and, although it can be difficult and non-sensical sometimes, as a good manager, you should be able to keep your best players at Strong/Proficient game shape for most of the season. (with the exception of the first week).

The argument to changing the GS reset to become random at the start of the year, is that it would introduce elements of uncontrollable randomness into the game. Which would suck.

Like some of the examples given, if your best player comes back from off-season training with bad game shape, and it takes you 4 weeks to get him back to respectable/strong GS, and you lose all 8 games in those 4 weeks because of this players poor game shape, then that is a pretty darn good argument as to why its absurd.

Look at it from a different perspective. In my league, several teams do not know how to manage game shape, and as such, their players under-perform. So their players under-perform because their managers don't know what they are doing. Poor management = poor performance. Good management = good performance. Just like all other aspects of this game.

If you introduced a concept into the game where a player masively underperforms due to some totally random uncontrollable factor, then you would probably see a lot of users not play this game.