BuzzerBeater Forums

BB Global (English) > Scrimmage Game Engine Feedback v2

Scrimmage Game Engine Feedback v2

Set priority
Show messages by
This Post:
00
87048.42 in reply to 87048.41
Date: 5/6/2009 11:54:22 AM
Overall Posts Rated:
154154
Well, I wouldn't expect wonders from PG with reb 6 (on PG position). It looks like rebounds are distributed towards positions (to both players so that would explain why lucky fan PF got some albeit the better rebounder of the two got more of course) based on height of the skill of both players at that postition
(or based on height of the skill of the better one or something like that) and based on position of course. It is just a theory I guess it worked this way before too, maybe it has more impact now.

This Post:
00
87048.43 in reply to 87048.42
Date: 5/6/2009 6:05:21 PM
River Legends
IV.14
Overall Posts Rated:
12131213
Yes. i already knew it. What i say is that he should won the rebounds by much more, he used real players as 3, 4 and 5. I went with lucky fans as SF and PF and i had (16) 57 Vs (17) 62 that he had, very few difference in my opinion.

Regards.

This Post:
00
87048.44 in reply to 87048.43
Date: 5/7/2009 1:59:06 PM
Overall Posts Rated:
00
third match with the new rebounding modell and i'm voting desperately for THE OLD ONE! the latest match was a real keeper (12735208).
come on??? both teams played man to man, the rebounding ratings were in my favor, too. And i got outrebounded 95 to 58???????? He pulled down 50 (FIFTY!) offensive rebounds, ARE YOU KIDDING ME?

Just to make it really great, my PF (830694) has the following skills (he played 45 Minutes):
Weekly salary:
$ 11 547
DMI: 53500
Age: 23
Inside Shot: strong Inside Def.: proficient
Rebounding: strong Shot Blocking: strong
he got outrebounded by the other PF (9110626) 31 to 16 (16 to 2 OR) in 48 Minutes!!
I doubt it, that an 30 year old PF with 2200$ weekly salary and a DMI of 5600 is the better rebounder in this matchup!!
(by the way, my other players on C, PF or SF weren't bad rebounders neither)





This Post:
00
87048.45 in reply to 87048.44
Date: 5/7/2009 3:58:21 PM
Overall Posts Rated:
11011101
Ahem, during today scrimmage I got 43 Offensive Rebounds. (12731489)
OMG, 43!

- Team Rating was:
Me - 6 (low)
My opponent - 5 (high)

- We both used Man to man defense

- My players:
PG - REB: respectable - 10 REB (4 OR) - 48 mins.
SG - REB: average - 6 REB (3 OR) - 48 mins.
SF - REB: pitiful - 16 REB (8 OR) - 48 mins.
PF - REB: respectable - 27 REB ( 14 OR) - 43 mins.
C - REB: wondrous - 23 REB (13 OR) - 41 mins.

Bench:
PF/C - REB average - 5 REB (1 OR) - 12 mins.

- My opponent's players:
PG - REB: mediocre - 1 REB (0 OR) - 29 mins
SG - REB: mediocre - 2 REB (0 OR) - 35 mins.
SF - REB: proficient - 9 REB (3 OR) - 48 mins
PF - REB: proficient - 12 REB (4 OR) - 35 mins
C - REB : prominent - 14 REB (7 OR) - 33 mins

I don't know his bench's skills, but it seems to be quite unrealistic that my team got 43 Offensive Rebounds.
My SF did a too great performance

This Post:
00
87048.46 in reply to 87048.45
Date: 5/7/2009 4:11:22 PM
Overall Posts Rated:
225225
How is the stamina on those two guys? And the Inside Shot on your small forward.

"I don't know half of you half as well as I should like; and I like less than half of you half as well as you deserve."
This Post:
00
87048.47 in reply to 87048.44
Date: 5/7/2009 4:11:54 PM
Overall Posts Rated:
246246
We made also a strange observation re: rebounding in today's scrimmage:


Look at (6764540) - he has atrocious Reb-level but is the Rebound champion in this game. In 41 minutes mainly as PF (a few minutes as center) he made 18 out of 61 rebounds (21 reb / 48 min) in my team.

My other PF & Cs in this game all have respectable reb level which allowed them only to achieve 20 reb / 48 min. The SF played 48 minutes, has strong reb and achieved 10 reb / 48 min.


I know my opponent's reb level is on average also respectable for the PFs and C.


Don't you think this should not happen?

This Post:
00
87048.48 in reply to 87048.1
Date: 5/7/2009 4:25:35 PM
Overall Posts Rated:
959959
i ahve an problem with rebounding, too.

I win the rebounding duell 78-53 with similiar ratings, with a rebounding 3 PF and C who both gets 15 boards - the rebounding of my opponent wasn't that strong too bot he plays with real C and even on PF i expect an advantage in this area from him:

(12734032)

About blocking, in my eyes the amount of blocks increase, about 33% which is good but still it is mainly a Guard/SF thing.

And even it is an improvement, i believe you could reduce the impact of blocking in salary too, because it will be still overpaid but if you raise the impact it maybe wasn't fair for people who train for the old system and have centers with less blocking.

This Post:
00
87048.50 in reply to 87048.49
Date: 5/7/2009 5:10:54 PM
Overall Posts Rated:
11011101
We are talking about this man:

Fabien Loiret (2541621)
Weekly salary: $ 3 174
DMI: 10500
Age: 23
Height: 6'1" / 185 cm
Potential: allstar *
Game Shape: respectable
Jump Shot: strong ↑ Jump Range: awful
Outside Def.: respectable Handling: inept
Driving: mediocre Passing: average
Inside Shot: average Inside Def.: inept
Rebounding: pitiful Shot Blocking: average
Stamina: awful Free Throw: pitiful

Experience: pitiful

*blush*

He's my cheerleader

This Post:
00
87048.52 in reply to 87048.51
Date: 5/7/2009 6:56:01 PM
Overall Posts Rated:
387387
I'll just add another "erm, surely rebounds were messed up this week" post, as I gave up 36 offensive rebounds.

Advertisement