BuzzerBeater Forums

But wouldn't the reasons the players today (training) are stronger/faster be applied to any player of "then" that we brought forward to "now"?
Same with putting LeBron "back". He wouldn't have the same training, nor would he have had the benefits he accrued since he was a kid.

For some strange reason, I'm going to just to do a hit and run with this one. I used to watch MJ play. A lot. We had a couple of season tickets right behind the Bulls bench (my dad sold most of them, they were quite profitable!) starting in 1987 and through the championship seasons. (Long story about how my dad got them, I'm not going to tell it since who know who could get in trouble over this, but the motivation was actually to just to get any season tickets since that was the easiest way to guarantee getting tickets to the All Star game that year.) Anyway, the point is, I saw MJ up close. Here are some things I'll just throw out there, think of them what you will.

I never ever ever saw another player who could seemingly just score whenever he wanted to like MJ did. He would get that look in his eye and you could send the whole team after him (hard to due with the defense rules in those days, and keep in mind that MJ didn't have to deal with "NBA-approved zone defenses" like LeBron does, even though the zones have been cut back since post-MJ implementation). Anyway, when MJ had the ball and he needed to score, he pretty much scored as he wanted. Yeah, everybody misses sometimes, even MJ sometimes, but wow, if you never saw it, you could never believe it.

MJ was a great defender. The best, nobody today is as good and tenacious as MJ. As long as he was defending somebody who wasn't really bigger than him. Scottie took care of them. MJ could shut down an opposing SG pretty well. A big part of his defense was the mental game. He perfected the trash talking. I hear he wasn't the "out-of-bounds" type who'd take shots at some guy personal stuff, but he could lay into somebody's game with his mouth and make guys mess themselves up as they tried to show MJ what kind of game they had. He also had great hands, practically invented the wrap around, and when he picked somebody's pocket you just knew what was coming next and you couldn't wait to see the replay at home. LeBron can guard just about anybody, big or small (except maybe MJ in his day). But LeBron can't finish a steal like MJ.

MJ once scored 63 points in a playoff game while getting guarded by Dennis Johnson. Yeah, DJ of the Celtics (a pretty darn good defender, one of the best of his generation). After MJ missed most of the season with a broken foot. It was only his second NBA season. And the Bulls had a really mediocre lineup, so it wasn't like the Celtics had to focus on guarding anybody else. (Dave Corzine? Kyle Macy? Orlando Woolridge? Charles Oakley?) Okay, the Bulls lost the game in OT. But wow.

MJ never said anything about how he was the bet player. He let other people do that for him. He also never made a TV show about himself when his contracts would expire.

MJ never tried to draw contact and do his scoring from the FT line. I grimace every time I see LeBron do that. I never root for fouls or injuries, but if one of these days somebody really smacks LeBron on one of those plays, it would be so deserved. You know what I'm talking about. It's when he does stuff like when he's 20 feet from the basket and does a pump fake, then leans towards the defender with this shoulder to try to get him to bump into him, and the goes up to shoot the ball. Come on, LeBron. That is so lame. MJ never did that. He went for the best shot, not the contact. Would MJ have even attempted that amazing right-hand-to-left-hand driving layup against the Lakers ('91 Finals I was there, two days after high school graduation, it was awesome!) if he was just looking for contact? MJ was a man.

MJ made his teammates better. If you couldn't hack it at practice, MJ chewed you up and spit you out That's why MJ and Pippen didn't get along so well sometimes before Pippen really played like a Hall-of-Famer. (Scottie is great in his own right, but I wonder how good he would have become without MJ in his face when the cameras weren't rolling.) Some

But wouldn't the reasons the players today (training) are stronger/faster be applied to any player of "then" that we brought forward to "now"?
Same with putting LeBron "back". He wouldn't have the same training, nor would he have had the benefits he accrued since he was a kid.

Nope. That's the pretty part of the time machine, we compare them as they are vs as they were and in that only scenario Lebron is better than michael Jordan because I´m quite sure MJ would have adapted his play and training to whatever was necessary to dominate. That mentality made him the best.

However, I also think Lebron makes his teammates better players, Cleveland finished regular season as number 1 with him and last without him, that's how important he was.

Fair enough... if that's the limits of the time machine then (so... we can't bring 'em back/forward when they're younger?), understood.

Sidenote: how do you guys think the Finals impacted this entire conversation?

AND finally, if we are trying to fake a time machine and put Lebron as he is now playing in the past, I'm quite sure he would be the best player and would dominate the League even above Jordan as he is taller, faster and stronger and has a very close talent. But is just an opinion, it's impossible to prove any of this.

First of all, if LeBron were to play in the past, he couldn't have been on steroids so domination is out of the question

BUT if we are trying to compare stats that's impossible as they don't face the same opposition and don't play the same kinda basketball.

agree with you on this one, However, Jordan did play in 2002 and played quite well so...

There's a reason for all those rule changes: Defenses started to get better and better, so the points per game were dropping and for marketing purposes it doesn't seem to be a good thing, to say the rules were changed to help other guards to be Jordan isn't serious. You disagree?? Watch the videos, watch a Bill Chamberlain game, then watch Lakers vs Celtics in the 80's, then Chicago vs Utah in the 90s, then the Kobe Shaq Lakers vs whatever in the 00s and then watch again last week final games.

Are you serious? Defense now in the NBA, is as poor as it ever was. If you watched playoff basketball when Jordan, Miller, and the Knicks in particular were playing you'd see what i mean.

watch Lakers vs Celtics in the 80s and you'll be surprised as how slow and naive were the defensive reactions. It looks like a training match, there's no D if you compare it with what you are used to watch today. It's all in youtube..

the 80s are NOT the discussion of the thread however physicality was at it's best back then.

So what you want to compare: impact in the game?? Mental attributes?? Jordan by a mile. No doubt. But that's as far as I'd go.

I will add defense, and team play(!) on Jordan's part, and involving everyone. He was a team-oriented player despite his scoring ability.

And for Lebron i would just add much more hype, and that's as far as i would go


EDIT: and the way he reacts to physical defenders that are on him is just awful, and childish

Last edited by Boston Celts at 6/15/2011 4:15:55 AM

I will add defense, and team play(!) on Jordan's part, and involving everyone. He was a team-oriented player despite his scoring ability.

And shooting. Jordan was a MUCH better shooter...

Fair enough... if that's the limits of the time machine then (so... we can't bring 'em back/forward when they're younger?), understood.

Sidenote: how do you guys think the Finals impacted this entire conversation?

A young current player (lebron in this example) is sent to past to play vs those players when they were playing (so young too).

The finals only made more visible what was already not a mistery: Lebron James (currently, at least) lacks the mental strenght required to match his talent.

Last edited by Supermán at 6/15/2011 6:19:28 AM

What makes you think Lebron is on steroids and former players like... KArl Malone... were not?? Karl Malone's body doesn't look more "natural".

I watched Jordan, I watched Miller and I watched the Knicks back in those days and I disagree with you. Defense back then was not even close than today's. Objects in rearview mirror may appear closer than they are. Check back the videos & compare open mindedly.

The 80s is not the point of discussion, I'm just trying to show how the game evolved. But it's not in the 80s there was no D-fence nad then in the Jordan era suddenly it appeared and we saw the best defenses ever and then when Jordan retired defenses suddenly dissapeared again as you seem to be saying...

Jordan's team play appeared late in his career, his first 5 or more years he was a go to basket player. Lebron has averaged 7 assists in his career. SO what you mean for a better team play?? Jordan had more leadership, no doubt, and he gave his teammates more confidence, I agree there 100% and he had a more positive attitude out of the field. But again, Cleveland with lebron were first and without were last, that may say something about Lebron.

Lebron has a ton of haters (me included). He earned that with his tatoo "The chosen one", with the show that ended up with him in Miami, with his attitude inside and outside the court, etc... but that's not what we are supossed to discuss here and I think many of you are writing very "hate-influenced"

I have a bud whose wife is a psychologist. She says she thinks LeBron has some anxiety issues.

But I disagree on D, and I think a large part of that's officiating: it was DEFINITELY tougher in the 80s - they could get away with a heap more. Hell, listen to Kevin McHale talk about the difference between now and then (he discussed this very point on NBA Today).

Defense back then was not even close than today's. Objects in rearview mirror may appear closer than they are. Check back the videos & compare open mindedly.

(http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mlolzcidq0o) - Bulls Pistons ECF '91, two of the best def in the NBA that year

(http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z-QbU-SBJQ8) - Bulls Heat EFC '11, two of the best def this year

Same intensity, frantic rotations on def trying to close down shooters, full court pressure. The main difference? Much better TV resolution!

Last edited by brian at 6/15/2011 9:50:14 AM