BuzzerBeater Forums

well his guards went 6/18 and 1/9 while his pf went 16/20 so i cant say i agree with u there

Who is preventing you to play LI? I looked at the game and your players. Are you sure his PF shooting 16-20 wasnt your team skills fault? Your SF in game has ID 2, your starting C was fouled out and replaced with 9k backup. No real help defence there to help stop that PF. Even if they came to help on defence, there was no way they could stop a decent inside scorer.
Using motion you can obviously have the same results if the opponent lacks in OD at a certain spot. (36141805)

Sorry, I'm jumping in here a little late. I'm actually tempted to slide this thread to the BB Global Forum since I'm not sure what the suggestion is here, but I'll leave it here for now.

Anyway, the real question I want to ask here is, would anybody suggest that using a three-center lineup is a good strategy? Is is something to try only if you are desperate? Or it is just a really bad idea that only works against bad teams or team that are heavily loaded with outside-oriented players and/or a player at the SF with poor ID and more likely to accumulate fouls?

I've seen the occasional conjecturing with a box score thrown in here or there, but I really would like to see a solid argument one way or another. I personally ran a 3C lineup out last week out of desperation (my regular starting SF is injured) in a game I figured I was probably going to lose anyway. My C playing at SF seems to have done okay, but he went against maybe the best "true SF" in my league and I wish I had a better outside defender in the position in retrospect. Do you all think I should expect better results if I try this again because it's a really good strategy, or did I get lucky that the game didn't go worse for me and it's generally good idea not to run a 3C lineup? I would like to see some real logical breakdown, maybe backed up by some data and statistical analysis. Maybe some serious nerds will chime in here.

maybe his pf going crazy was my teams fault

my sfs id shouldnt be an issue, i played man2man and there werent any examples of his pf shooting over my sf

my pf is a good defender for this standard of league probably a bit above average - obv my backup pf is below average - thats why hes the backup & every time he was on their pf scored on him easily

no-one is preventing me from playing look inside that is why i am selling 1/2 my team and will be making a look inside team myself for next season - if u cant beat them join them - the game engine is obviously broken in favour of look inside so i am selling the guys i have had for seasons and ill just play the way everyone else does and win more

see problem solved :P

LI is strong and 2-3 weak because of BB's overall talent pool. Also 2-3 is not a natural counter to LI, especially if you don't have the right personnel. In order to counter two great big men, it's better to have two great ID guys and play m2m. Just as it would be in real basketball.

I actually think today's best LI attacks are very easy to counter, and in a few seasons LI will no longer be the "best" tactic in the game as cross-trained players balance the talent pool. It already isn't the best tactic in BB, it's just that not enough people are doing the right things to stop it.

Last edited by RiseandFire at 10/1/2011 12:03:17 AM

It already isn't the best tactic in BB, it's just that not enough people are doing the right things to stop it.

Elaborate on this part...

are you serious..?
49.999 managers in this game should be fools then..

I AM THE 1%

Elaborate on this part...

There are few forwards in this game who can defend properly. LI is easy to exploit because if you have a SF who can penetrate and finish, the defense will rotate to him and your center will get open for easy buckets all game long. SFs should have good OD and ID on defense, but there's a stupid "guards vs. bigs" dichotomy in BB and nobody takes the time to train good forwards. PFs generally don't have nearly enough OD, either.

I actually think today's best LI attacks are very easy to counter..

so all u need is a sf with phenomenal od and prodigious id

and a pf with phenomenal id and wondrous od

ok that should be easy, u said it was very easy, lets go shopping on the tl

oh none

lets drop them a bit still none

lets drop both to wondrous oh still none

lets drop both to tremendous - we have a winner and only $5,000,000!

u said it is very easy, it isnt easy out of all the thousands of guys on the tl there isnt a single double wondrous at any price the best we can find is double tremendous & do u really claim that tremendous id will stop "the best inside attacks"

did a search for phenomonal + ID total 20
guess what the ODs are?
2 inept
2 awful
8 pitiful
8 atrocious

so the best possible od i can match with the great id is inept

maybe ill just train one of my own, easy right?