BuzzerBeater Forums

Help - English > Messed up game horrible

Messed up game horrible

Set priority
Show messages by
This Post:
00
293964.5 in reply to 293964.4
Date: 04/24/2018 05:18:32
Overall Posts Rated:
2222
Thanks for the reply mate. Okay great, that makes sense. Will my players get stats for the game? Cheers

This Post:
00
293964.6 in reply to 293964.5
Date: 04/24/2018 10:27:28
Overall Posts Rated:
32293229
Thanks for the reply mate. Okay great, that makes sense. Will my players get stats for the game? Cheers


No, they'll just have minutes played (for gameshape and training purposes), and they'll possibly get injured unless that changed in the past several seasons and I've forgotten.

This Post:
00
293964.8 in reply to 293964.6
Date: 04/25/2018 08:19:24
Overall Posts Rated:
14901490
Yes I think this sucks for MVP, All-star etc, because for that the number of games played and minutes actually matter. Not just averages.

This Post:
00
293964.9 in reply to 293964.7
Date: 04/25/2018 19:43:24
Durham Wasps
EBBL
Overall Posts Rated:
16541654
Second Team:
Sunderland Boilermakers
Injury is still possible as a trade off to GS/training minutes.

There's no trade off here. Your opponent doesn't show up, there's no game. There should be no chance of injury. You're saying there's a trade off because that's how the game is. You get GS/training minutes because there's no alternative. It would punish the victim. The same way an injury does. Should be fixed. What you are saying, and have said before in previous conversations is nonsense.

This Post:
00
293964.11 in reply to 293964.9
Date: 04/26/2018 14:48:14
Overall Posts Rated:
32293229
Injury is still possible as a trade off to GS/training minutes.

There's no trade off here. Your opponent doesn't show up, there's no game. There should be no chance of injury. You're saying there's a trade off because that's how the game is. You get GS/training minutes because there's no alternative. It would punish the victim. The same way an injury does. Should be fixed. What you are saying, and have said before in previous conversations is nonsense.


If there's no game, then nobody plays, and therefore no minutes are gained for training or gameshape purposes. I don't think that's a preferable alternative by any stretch. One could alternately just give a bunch of crappy players in the form of lucky fans to the team that didn't field anyone so a lineup could be fielded, but that would be rewarding the bad behavior by turning a zero percent chance of winning into a non-zero one, without risk to that team's own players. A random lineup of the players who exist on the roster could be forced, but again this would be harsh to the team who actually submitted a lineup, and doubly so a team has multiple walkovers and different lineups get selected against different teams.

The current methodology is imperfect as well (and I might well go with the five lucky fans as long as I could ensure they had minimum levels of agression), but it's the closest to the status quo: You made the effort to submit a lineup, therefore your players will receive minutes with the risk of injury. Ideally, the scenario should be as close as possible to what happens if your opponent does submit a lineup, except of course my preference is that a team that doesn't submit a lineup should be guaranteed to lose the game with a forfeit penalty, plus lose other economic /training benefits from the game.

This Post:
00
293964.12 in reply to 293964.11
Date: 04/26/2018 18:04:27
Durham Wasps
EBBL
Overall Posts Rated:
16541654
Second Team:
Sunderland Boilermakers
If there's no game, then nobody plays, and therefore no minutes are gained for training or gameshape purposes. I don't think that's a preferable alternative by any stretch.

Never said it was preferable. Indeed I covered that:

You get GS/training minutes because there's no alternative. It would punish the victim.

This Post:
00
293964.13 in reply to 293964.12
Date: 04/27/2018 09:32:08
Overall Posts Rated:
32293229
If there's no game, then nobody plays, and therefore no minutes are gained for training or gameshape purposes. I don't think that's a preferable alternative by any stretch.

Never said it was preferable. Indeed I covered that:

You get GS/training minutes because there's no alternative. It would punish the victim.


Never said you said it was. I was merely elaborating my thoughts on various alternatives, which are admittedly far from profound, but I'm a little disappointed that they were poor enough that apparently all that came across was the thought that I was putting words into your mouth in order to shut down those words.

Last edited by GM-hrudey at 04/27/2018 09:32:57