Ive only briefly read through this thread, but from what I can tell Tuck was going for a result like this:
(18340). In which case if he was trying to have the C take the most outside shots he made the right choice, by throwing up an inverted patient. He should have put Sharpling at C though. Dont see why Gascoigne was at C? I mean Sharpling at C and then switching their defensive assignments makes a lot more sense..