If you don't understand anything, why you say "worst idea ever"? (same for the guys that upvoted it)
I mean, if you don't understand, just say "I don't understand your idea" and I will try to explain it better. But if you just say it is bullshit just because you don't understand something, you will always be an ignorant.
To start with, you manage to be incoherent in just three lines, which is quite an accomplishment.
(1) "So anyone could just easy get other person players w/o any work done"
is incoherent with
(2) " there is no chance for new players to catch up"
but you even say that both statements are the same!!!
Reality is, if well implemented, a new team could pay few salary, just like it is now. To be able to pay more salary, the team will need:
(1) Get more income through building infrastructure (arena ...)
(2) Find the way to promote, because higher league means higher income.
(3) Train good players because the training team will get a small percentage of their salary (as I said in my second post that I guess you didn't read)
And of course the manager has to learn how the game engine works and how valuable each player is, because that is the way to train good players and to bid well and not pay too much to the players.
So basically the game would have a steep learning process for new managers. Just like is now. And just like should be in a good strategy game. Nothing changes in this respect and your critiques are baseless.