BuzzerBeater Forums

All I see is players with large bank roll abuse this. Players with a large bank roll are already at an advantage. This system will amplify it, if I don’t care about how much I spend. I’ll just set it to auto max bid with an absurd price.

Almost very good, but fear no more. I got you.

Everything is fine except one.

"- the feature is only available 24 hours before the auctions ends. (something in that nature, not open for discussion)"

This is almost good, but as it is, it would be a huge advantage for bigger teams, with bigger money. An easy fix, is to set and end for auto bids. Or am i to understand that all auto bids will end at 3 min, so there is still a chance for smaller teams to snipe a good player for a lower price? Could that timer maybe start from 15 min then? or 10 ? just so there is an amount of time, where you can still win a good player, if you put in the dedication to actually follow the transfer live.

I feel like i have made a trade or two, by monitoring the transfer marked. And i would be sad to see that part leave.

Literally couldnt have said it better myself!! Its frustrating to lose players but sometimes players are worth a bathroom break it makes winning a bid so tantalizing. New managers also have the ability to get under valued players (usually in weird time zones) that they can then flip to allow super slick newbies to jump leagues faster. Its a strange system ive always thought i hated it until the thought of it switching was brought to the table. Definitely keep it!!

Id argue that inter league scouting should be an option! (eventually allowing for interdivision trading which would be dope!!). That would allow for more tatics to be brought in thus increasing manager activity!!

Incredibly against this. Part of what makes the game fun is getting a bargain on a guy because someone didn’t login to start a bidding war. This takes out a lot of the fun, and will cause a pretty sizable price increase for a lot of middle tier players imo. It sounds good in practice, but ultimately makes the market much more efficient which makes it much harder to get a steal or have fun with the auction. I’ve lost countless auctions because I’ve forgotten to log in and I’ve always been against this.

I just think this leaves lasting impacts on the economy and makes it even more challenging to get a player you really want through the TL.

One thing that seems apparent after reading most of the responses. The people saying NO might be outvoted right now but they are certainly more passionate about their position.

Hello Alonso, I like this motion, it's like it's done in the game Hattrick, but I'd like you to add this:

1- Only 1 automatic bid for non-supporter.
2- Unlimited automatic bids for supporters and/or not 5-10 maximum, for this type of users. You have to give certain benefits to the paying users.
3- Improve the comparison of transfers, because, perhaps there may be people who will profit endemic for this. Thinking that maybe people place maximum bids above the comparator. This point isn't so necessary, but it's like an idea of what might happen in the future, don't you know?


Off topic, please alonso can you go to NT Coach thread and read something you post to help us with that request? It won't take long.

Greetings and thank you.



_____________________________________________________________________________________________

Hola Alonso, me gusta esta moción, es como se hace en el juego Hattrick, pero me gustaría que agregan esto:

1- Solo 1 Puja automatica para no supporter.
2- Ilimitadas pujas automaticas para los supporter y/o no se 5-10 máximo, para este tipo de usuarios. Tienes que darle ciertos beneficios a los usuarios que pagan.
3- Mejoren el comparador de transferencias, porque, a lo mejor peuden haber gente que se vaya a lucrar endemasia por esto. Pensando en que quizas la gente coloque pujas máxima por encima del comparador. Este punto no es tan necesario, pero es como una idea de lo que quizas puede que pase a futuro, no se?


Off topic, por favor alonso puedes ir al hilo de NT Coach y leer algo que publique para que nos ayudes con esa solicitud? No les tomará mucho tiempo.

Saludos y gracias.

I strongly disagree with the autobid probably for 9 out of 10 reasons mentioned above. Also as I am writing this post only 410 users ( give or take ) have voted which is 2,8% of the total users in the game . Imho it is not an adequate percentage no matter the result.

People were getting banned not so long ago for using autoclick programs, and now you propose it as a viable change?? We should be really really careful when it comes to the future of the game.

I like the idea, but I don't think that it goes far enough. You guys are going to absolutely hate this post, but I would rather see a buy now price as opposed to a max bid. I hate waking up in the morning to see that I lost a player by one bid or a few thousand dollars.

For the rest of you concerned that rich teams will corner the market I would counter that the sim still has rules that govern your team's finances. You can't just employ 30 guys with million dollar salaries. You would still have to be able to manage your payroll.

Your suggestion starts to lean towards pay to win in my opinion. If auto bid is implemented (which I hope it isn’t) it needs to be the same for everyone.

you couldn´t have said it better,
I completely agree with you

I cannot believe so many people think this feature will create a disadvantage for poor teams in favor or richer teams

It doesn´t seem to me that this people care about the future of this game. To me, one of the first reasons for people to give up this kind of games is when yo feel the game is no fair. I mean, when the rules or the mechanisms of the games seems to favour a way of playing which doesn´t feel right for you. For example when you find a very nice game but the structure is pay to win.
One of the beautiful things about hattrick or buzzerbeater is that, there is no pay to win structures. However, the absence of mechanism like auto-bid create and enviroment which encourage players to spend a lot of times in order to get players.
In my opinion the game should reward players who make great strategies or great decisions, not players who are able to spend their life online
To me this feature would make this game much more fair, and would ease people who sometimes tend to give up because they don´t have the time to compete in bids and bids and bids. And of course, I love the exciment of war bidding, but I care more for a fair enviroment and give the same options to everyone. All of you that said if you want a player, no one stop you from offer whatever you think is fair. Thats not the point, you should have the same possibilitties than other to get the player at the best price.

all in all, to me a game with auto-bid system is much more fair than a game without it, and that should be enough to get you to aprove this proposition

Anyway, It was a pleasure to have the opportunity of gave our approach and listen other people who think so different to me

Concuerdo con tu punto de vista, solo que lo haría igual que hattrick, todos los no supporter hacer 1 oferta máxima, y los supporter pueden hacer algunas mas.