BuzzerBeater Forums

Suggestions > Pillory

Pillory

Set priority
Show messages by
This Post:
00
174125.7 in reply to 174125.5
Date: 2/10/2011 4:55:10 AM
Overall Posts Rated:
291291
what is the point for all this secrecy anyway???
if u did something wrong-punishment is what u deserve, and since we are all invited to report anything wrong in this way we should see that someone is getting our complain seriously and is doing something by banning/giving a fine

i agree with the proposal

This Post:
22
174125.9 in reply to 174125.6
Date: 2/10/2011 5:00:04 AM
Overall Posts Rated:
406406
Why don't you know how the community should benefit?
I think it's very simple:

(Potential) Cheaters, wo think about cheating in the future will scared off, so they don't gonna cheat.
Players who cheat currently, will also scared about it, so they stop maybe before they caught.
So I think it makes the game more fair in total :)


I think it will ruin some managers reputation and drive them off the game if they were fined a smaller amount of money for a transfer. There surely would be a witch-hunt every now and then - I think that would do more damage than improve the game.

This Post:
00
174125.10 in reply to 174125.8
Date: 2/10/2011 5:08:39 AM
Overall Posts Rated:
522522
Every report is read and review. If nothing happens, it's because GM think there is nothing wrong.


But the point is that even if something happens no one except the GMs know about it.

In real life, if someone commits murder, or steals something, it isn't tucked away in a corner, the trial is open for people to see, and so is the final decision as well as the reasons and what the punishment was.

This is what I would like to see happen here as well.

This Post:
00
174125.11 in reply to 174125.9
Date: 2/10/2011 5:22:00 AM
Overall Posts Rated:
6868
I think it will ruin some managers reputation and drive them off the game if they were fined a smaller amount of money for a transfer. There surely would be a witch-hunt every now and then - I think that would do more damage than improve the game.



Yeah, it maybe does, but the players who look at that list, know the reputation of that players. It is not deffinetly cheating, placing a higher bid on a player. Players who look on that list, know that.
And the people who really cheat, are not worth a reputation, so place them on that list

When I run into an invisible spider web, I instantly become a kung-fu master.
This Post:
00
174125.12 in reply to 174125.11
Date: 2/10/2011 5:32:29 AM
Overall Posts Rated:
7070
Thumbs up for akage14.I agree with this idea.People that have been punished before for "slight" cheating should be known to the public.This way people will keep an eye on them so that they dont do it again.

From: CrazyEye

To: Nick
This Post:
11
174125.13 in reply to 174125.6
Date: 2/10/2011 5:38:24 AM
Overall Posts Rated:
959959
Why don't you know how the community should benefit?
I think it's very simple:

(Potential) Cheaters, wo think about cheating in the future will scared off, so they don't gonna cheat.
Players who cheat currently, will also scared about it, so they stop maybe before they caught.
So I think it makes the game more fair in total :)


I could imagine that it will encourage light cheating, and endless discussions.

Because when i know i get fined like this for doing that, i could check if it worth it to risk it and also people come on complaining and say why this guy get a 200k fine for this transfer and i got a 250k fine for a similiar transfer etc.

Shouldn't be that list scaring enough for cheaters? -> http://www.buzzerbeater.com/community/cheatReport.aspx

This Post:
00
174125.14 in reply to 174125.13
Date: 2/10/2011 5:41:31 AM
Overall Posts Rated:
522522
That list isn't scary enough at all.

Despite the potential for complaints, I still think it is a brilliant idea.
Just look at the example I gave compared to the real life. People in life could complain that one murderer got 10 years in prison and the other murderer got 15 years in prison, but that doesn't mean it shouldn't be open to the public. You can't say that this will encourage people in real life to commit small crimes.

From: Nick

This Post:
00
174125.15 in reply to 174125.13
Date: 2/10/2011 5:41:59 AM
Overall Posts Rated:
6868
Hmm, you're right.
Maybe it's an idea to make the list anonymous? So people can see what kind of punishments were given, but complaints about reputations and discussions are not possible...?

When I run into an invisible spider web, I instantly become a kung-fu master.
From: Thor
This Post:
11
174125.17 in reply to 174125.15
Date: 2/10/2011 5:58:18 AM
Overall Posts Rated:
291291
i personnaly think -am not trying to insult anyone- that there is a bit of a hypocrisy here...

i think what akage is proposing is a mere list of all punishments the GMs inflict.

just a list and the reason for the penalty...

no public courts.

someone mentioned about the reputation and so one... i will still respect someone who got a fine for bidding more than he should cause he learned his lesson. i wont respect someone who has 2-3 and more teams and transfers players...

relax people...its just a list.And i think all of us who are commenting to this post we shouldnt fear to be judged? i hope am right ;)))

Advertisement