BuzzerBeater Forums

thats y i think that the 2nd one will be a better PG.

No you described why the second player would be easier to train, but not the better point guard. The first option would be the better point guard.

yeah i know that i described that the second player is easier to train.probably coz the manager is still planning to train them.if he would be searching the player on the TL then i would have gone for the 2nd player.
i just gave equal value to skills and training time.
i know my opinion and reason is not much appreciable but thats what i thought.

From the wording of the post he is asking which will be the best final product.

First is better then second at all.
But I didnt like any of them. As I believe in balanced players.

i go for the second, the OD is good enough for the BB(i was there last season, with mx this OD and OD 13 bench guards ;)). AND jr Maybe not that important then JS, but respectable is the value i expect from my PF as a minimum, i would go down 1 and add it to JS or generally push him more in JS in exchange for a bit D and passing.

I'll trust you(mainly because you have one of the best teams in the world) and I'll go for the 11/9/15 instead of the other two(11/7/17 or 10/10/15). Thank you everyone for your answers.

Excuse me for hijacking this:

Jump Shot: sensational Jump Range: proficient
Outside Def.: prodigious Handling: sensational
Driving: prominent Passing: prolific
Inside Shot: awful Inside Def.: inept
Rebounding: respectable Shot Blocking: respectable

or

Jump Shot: sensational Jump Range: respectable
Outside Def.: marvelous Handling: prolific
Driving: prolific Passing: tremendous
Inside Shot: pitiful Inside Def.: strong
Rebounding: atrocious Shot Blocking: awful

Who'd you keep as your Pg (will be moving to D.II next season)?

Thanks for the help!

Assuming none of them is trainable, I would pick the first one - he has better JR, slightly better OD and IS, and a lot of RB and SB for a guard, which is always handy.
The second one's biggest advantage is his high passing + his ID is great, but I would still pick the first one.

i would go for the first one too, both aren't looking like the point guard i prefer but the second one could also become a solid PG/SG backup in the future.

@Dodor and Crazyeye:

Thanks for the advice. Both are in fact capped (or I might be still training them). I was trending toward the first player as well. We will see if I have to sell the other to improve my SG position.

Double Hi-jacking thread

this will be my second season in D.4 USA and I was trying to decide between my three PG back-ups which one I want to keep. I mainly run LI and R&G (if that makes any difference). I'm also training bigs so these are probably not gonna see much training other than a FT or Stamina team train every blue moon.


Weekly salary: $ 4 623
Role: regular starter
(BuzzerBeta)

DMI: 21700
Age: 31
Height: 6'1" / 185 cm
Potential: perennial allstar

Jump Shot: average Jump Range: respectable
Outside Def.: respectable Handling: average
Driving: strong Passing: respectable
Inside Shot: atrocious Inside Def.: awful
Rebounding: average Shot Blocking: atrocious
Stamina: strong Free Throw: average

Experience: inept

or

Weekly salary: $ 3 074
Role: backup
(BuzzerBeta)

DMI: 9800
Age: 23
Height: 6'2" / 188 cm
Potential: starter

Jump Shot: respectable Jump Range: awful
Outside Def.: respectable Handling: strong
Driving: mediocre Passing: average
Inside Shot: respectable Inside Def.: average
Rebounding: awful Shot Blocking: awful
Stamina: respectable Free Throw: proficient

Experience: atrocious

or

Weekly salary: $ 2 001
Role: backup
(BuzzerBeta)

DMI: 18000
Age: 23
Height: 6'1" / 185 cm
Potential: allstar

Jump Shot: respectable Jump Range: awful
Outside Def.: average Handling: respectable
Driving: inept Passing: inept
Inside Shot: average Inside Def.: atrocious
Rebounding: atrocious Shot Blocking: average
Stamina: respectable Free Throw: proficient

Experience: atrocious

Thanks again for any help or tips.