BuzzerBeater Forums

The Draft is random if you want it that way = No scout.

I like it but it must be just on the top 3 picks. It's unfair if they win the championship + 1st pick. Haha xD

The Draft is random if you want it that way = No scout.

Nope.
The draftees are generated randomly every season in every league. Of course the generation is not entirely random, but some seasons you can find 3 MVPs + 1 hall of famer, and the next season you can barely find 1 MVP. That's random.

The lottery should be for the top 4 picks (worst 4 teams). You could also break it in to pods.
4 worst teams draw for top 4 spots. next 4, next 4, next 4. This way the draft benefits the teams it should. The team who finishes dead last should not have to suffer by getting the 6,7,8 overall pick. You could also adjust the pods so that the top two teams auto get the last 2 picks. Top 4, next 4, next 6.

its not a bad idea, but i just don't see the point and here is why.

Go have a look at your leagues draft history - and look in round 1.

Look at the preference that everyone got. 99% of the time, people got their 1st, 2nd or 3rd preference in the first round.
If I look at my league, last seasons draft, only 3 teams DIDNT get their first preference (they got their 2nd or 3rd).
The previous season - 6 teams didnt get their 1st preference, but they got their 2nd and 3rd (and the person drafting last, got their 4th preference)

Season 25 - only 2 teams didn't get their first preference, but they got their 2nd.

Point im trying to make - is that teams generally get their first preference anyways - SO even if you had a draft lottery, it isnt going to change anything, the team that picks first/2nd, 3rd, 4th, last, is still very very likely to get their first preference.

So why have a lottery? If you going to pick 5th and still get your 1st preference, then who cares if you pick 5th, or 1st, or 2nd, or 6th.

Make sense?

"Lottery for the top 4 picks only" sounds good ...

But I think the rest ( pick 5~48) should be in order, just like the same as right now.

no for the same reason the nba is considering changing it, random teams on the cusp of being good like the cavs in real life can get the #1 pick.