i found the bug, and mark is fixing it... you'll notice if you swap who is team1 and who is team2 in the url, who gets all the wins swaps around..... so it was simply the fact that we were counting games and then counting wins for 1 team for the various columns on the right.. you'll notice which dont include PLs and then assuming the rest of the games were won by the other guy. A speedier way to do it, but when you dont have a case to look for PL wins it gets it wrong.