It will be higher in the second case. However, it will be higher in the second case no matter which attitude level you chose - the TIE in the first game allows your team to have stronger defensive ratings in the second game anyway, even with another TIE. However, in the match after the CT, your rating will be lower than in your first game, while with another crunch time they increase even more (even though they stabilize once the enthusiasm reaches about 10)
However, a change in the attitude level itself does not have an influence on the team ratings in the box score. Still, it will be visible which attitude you chose - you simply get better outsomes with CT than with normal than with TIE. Still, the long-term costs of using CT might be quite high ;)