BuzzerBeater Forums

BB Global (English) > The Quest for the Formulas

The Quest for the Formulas (thread closed)

Set priority
Show messages by
This Post:
00
46657.95 in reply to 46657.1
Date: 1/31/2009 9:15:49 AM
Overall Posts Rated:
404404
Is there some news for us?

This Post:
00
46657.97 in reply to 46657.96
Date: 2/11/2009 8:06:54 AM
Overall Posts Rated:
409409
4) A larger role than I thought earlier is played by the energy-characteristics of each tactic. For example the energy-characteristics of a defensive tactic (fast-slow etc.) will have an impact on offensive team ratings and vice versa.


When you talk about energy-characteristics of tactics you mean, pace?

If that's true, this is really unexpected for me. As far as I knew pace had and impact on the game, but I believed it was completely related to way in wich my players would behave (like, when chossing to shot or not) rather than actually have an impact on their perforance via stamina speed decreasement.

Maybe I just got it all wrong...

Another question, What about Shape? It works as multiplier of skills? Do you have any clue about how much important it is?

This Post:
00
46657.99 in reply to 46657.96
Date: 2/11/2009 9:48:39 AM
Overall Posts Rated:
404404
1) My earlier regressions were full of artefacts. Much fewer position/skill-pairs are used in each team rating than I used to think. The idea that there is a fully spelled out position/skill matrix for each offensive and defensive tactic, using many different skills for each of the ratings, was almost definitely wrong. BB-Forrest invested only half an hour after all ;-)

2) Usually there'll be a set of position/skill-coefficients for each team rating. That set will be relatively simple. I've calculated some new approximations, but I still don't disclose them. There are now 192 games in the database, a minimum of 14 for each tactic, and at least 2 games with each of the 40 possible combinations of tactics.

3) The contribution of each position to each rating will be modified by a tactic-dependent multiplier. I'm currently not sure whether the relative weight of each skill used at a certain position as compared to the other skills used at that position is really also tactic-dependent. The new regressions are not conclusive on this.

4) A larger role than I thought earlier is played by the energy-characteristics of each tactic. For example the energy-characteristics of a defensive tactic (fast-slow etc.) will have an impact on offensive team ratings and vice versa. These energy effects cannot be derived fully from the boxscores, since it will make a difference whether a player plays 36 minutes in one go or whether he plays 18 minutes, rests 12, and then plays another 18. Building a better model of the energy effects of the stamina skill is now the main challenge for future work.

5) Team ratings are not used by the game engine code, and they really only tell a very incomplete story. For instance some skills seem to be absent from the computation of all six team ratings, which doesn't mean that they won't have an impact in actual games.

Point 2 ,3 are known as principle,but a more deep research about it should be great,so we can batter explain some evaluations in strange matches
Point 4 should be analyzed compared with the stamina level of the players,but these confirms some theories about the importance of have a good bench(when one player is tired a good bench consent to rest the starter)or to have a great level of stamina for starters
Point 1 e 5 iIagree,the Free throws skill for example can give many points,but the team reatings doens't count it in the game

Message deleted
This Post:
00
46657.101 in reply to 46657.100
Date: 2/15/2009 6:36:10 AM
Overall Posts Rated:
00
It occurs that (maybe this has been pointed out upthread) - if we had more data on the salary calculation, and hence could get a little closer, we would actually be able to work out player sublevels when the salaries reset!

You say you've looked at about 200 transfer listed players - I'm sure it wouldn't be hard at all to get five times that number with some community effort, and I'd be happy to write a python script to convert the entries to csv so that you don't have to enter them manually...

This Post:
00
46657.103 in reply to 46657.98
Date: 2/16/2009 2:56:41 PM
Overall Posts Rated:
409409
however, energy is probably not equally important for all aspects of the game

I think the same here.

I believe it's a multiplier very similar to the way it works in hattrick.


Is it already know the exact impact of Shape in HT? I don't play it so I'm not aware of the situation there. I imagine how it works when talking about the multiplier but I do not know if is known the value of it.

A Hint on this might be that I suspect that the impact of shape in skils is non linear. Have you looked at this?

This Post:
00
46657.105 in reply to 46657.104
Date: 3/20/2009 10:18:05 AM
Overall Posts Rated:
404404
What's the impact of experience about skills?


Advertisement