BuzzerBeater Forums

Australia - IV.7 > Season 5 MVP appeals

Season 5 MVP appeals

Set priority
Show messages by
From: mllama
This Post:
11
190297.1
Date: 07/22/2011 23:36:07
Overall Posts Rated:
326326
Sorry Sass, just have to do it, can't let Fatur win back to back! ;)

Appealing in the Black label society v Zazzocalypse game

The original decision was Fatur 3 votes, Svornic 2 votes, Howarth 1 vote.

I contend that :

Fatur doesn't deserve any votes - he shot 5-19 and had a pretty mediocre game by his standards

Zuras was hard done by, he shot efficiently, rebounded, and defended outstandingly.

So I'll appeal, and suggest: Zuras 3 votes, Svornix 2 votes, Howarth 1 vote. Could also switch Howarth and Zuras around.

C-Cat do your thang!

Last edited by mllama at 07/22/2011 23:36:39

From: yodabig

This Post:
00
190297.2 in reply to 190297.1
Date: 07/23/2011 00:09:34
Overall Posts Rated:
14651465
Awesome appeal. I will put on the Bat Signal!

This Post:
00
190297.3 in reply to 190297.2
Date: 07/23/2011 01:04:58
Overall Posts Rated:
222222
Does mllama have standing to appeal this decision? :P I thought we could only appeal games we were involved in.

This Post:
00
190297.4 in reply to 190297.3
Date: 07/23/2011 02:03:08
Overall Posts Rated:
326326
Not sure, dunno where the appeals rules are

Thinks its been done before though, but I may be mistaken, but I'm not to fussed if I can't ;)

This Post:
00
190297.5 in reply to 190297.3
Date: 07/23/2011 02:23:26
Overall Posts Rated:
612612
i think you are able to appeal any game but if you lose it, thats it

Garrie Addison (18085302). The G-Adder striking blows since season 15
This Post:
00
190297.6 in reply to 190297.5
Date: 07/23/2011 03:17:40
Overall Posts Rated:
522522
You are right, anyone can appeal any game. But they only get to keep their right to appeal future games if they win that particular appeal.

This Post:
00
190297.7 in reply to 190297.6
Date: 07/23/2011 04:07:12
Overall Posts Rated:
809809
i tried 2 find the rules but failed

we need naker or yoda or ccat 2 show us

This Post:
00
190297.8 in reply to 190297.7
Date: 07/23/2011 04:49:16
Overall Posts Rated:
214214
Well, if it turns out that mllama can't do it then i'll back him and lodge it myself. Grgur had quite a mediocre game really and Zuras and Howorth were the leaders of this one. Howorth played SF but defended at SG and vice versa for Zuras so i'd say that Zuras deserves the 3 votes as he was efficient offensively and completely shutdown his opponent defensively. Howorth the 2 and Svorinic the 1.
I'm not sure why the votes seem to follow a Team A, Team B, Team A sort of format most of the time but i disagree with that. Svorinic scored 30 points but shot 10-26 and was a team worth -21 in the +- so not all that valuable for the team. Considering they lost by 12, the team was actually 7 points better off without him on the court.

This Post:
00
190297.9 in reply to 190297.8
Date: 07/23/2011 04:53:26
Overall Posts Rated:
4949
it is for that reason that i will never be doing the write ups again ... i cant be relied upon to objectively judge anything

"the labor party cant even spell surplus, let alone deliver one"
This Post:
00
190297.10 in reply to 190297.9
Date: 07/23/2011 05:02:18
Overall Posts Rated:
214214
Haha i wasn't trying to have a go at you. Especially since it was a drunken write up, i'd say you did pretty well. There's always going to be a game here or there throughout the season through the leagues that needs to be reviewed, even sober ones! :P

This Post:
00
190297.11 in reply to 190297.8
Date: 07/23/2011 05:06:59
Overall Posts Rated:
14651465
Don't worry Smeltz you did a great job, one little mistake doesn't matter as long as the main job is done and we have a hassle free and friendly appeals process.

The A B A or often A A B votes format are mostly mine, it is the school teacher in me still wanting to give something to the losing side. Heck I have even given 2 or even 3 once to a player from the losing side in a blowout if they really were the best player on the court by a mile. I certainly don't try to follow any pattern but I do try to give the losing team something if they had at least one player who was good.

I think for this particular case Judge C-Cat will have a very easy time.